ESG Screening

Blog

Documenting a site-level ESG finding for an engagement letter

Aerial view of a large open-pit mine with terraced soil layers and machinery.

When a site flag comes back from a screening pass, the hard part isn't spotting it. It's writing it up in a way that holds together once it's sitting in an engagement letter next to the company's own disclosure. Engagement letters get read by the portfolio company's IR team, sometimes by outside counsel, and eventually by your own investment committee if the issue escalates. Vague language in that letter just invites a vague response back.

What the letter needs that a screenshot doesn't

A cropped satellite image dropped into an email thread is thin ground for an analyst to stand on in writing. The engagement letter needs four things, stated plainly, before the finding goes anywhere near a company contact:

  • The site identity: facility name as it appears in the company's own ESG report or 10-K footprint disclosure, plus coordinates if the company hasn't named the parcel precisely.
  • The observation window: specific calendar dates bounding when the change was detected, stated as a range such as "between the March and June passes," rather than a loose reference to recent imagery.
  • What changed: described in terms the company can check against its own records (footprint area, canopy loss acreage, a new flare stack visible where none was reported, cleared buffer along a waterway).
  • What it's being compared against: the company's last self-reported figure, the prior quarter's screen, or both.

Skip any of those four and the letter reads as an accusation instead of a question. The goal of a site flag in an engagement letter is almost never "you are lying." It's "here's a gap between what you told investors and what the imagery shows, please explain it." That framing only works if the dates and the comparison baseline are in the letter itself, not held back for a follow-up call.

A documentation format that survives a counsel read

Most stewardship teams land on something close to this structure for a site-level finding, whether it's going into an engagement letter, an internal escalation memo, or a proxy voting rationale:

  1. Holding and site. Ticker or fund position, facility name, country, coordinates.
  2. Disclosure on file. What the company has reported for this site: land use, flaring volume, tailings facility classification, whatever is relevant to the finding.
  3. Observed condition. The change, with the imagery date range and source resolution noted. If the pass was medium-resolution multispectral at a 3–10 m ground sample distance, say so. A counsel reading this later will want to know what the imagery could and couldn't resolve.
  4. Delta. The specific gap between line 2 and line 3, in a sentence, not a paragraph.
  5. Request. What you're asking the company to confirm, correct, or provide documentation for.

Keep the observed-condition section descriptive, not conclusory. "Tailings impoundment footprint increased by an estimated X hectares between the Q1 and Q2 passes" is defensible. "Company is concealing tailings expansion" is a conclusion a stewardship analyst shouldn't draw from a satellite pass alone, no matter how clear the change looks on screen.

Sourcing and dating the imagery correctly

The citation line matters more than people think when a finding gets challenged. At minimum, note the satellite pass date (or date range for a quarterly screen), the resolution class, and whether the comparison is against the prior quarter's pass or an older baseline. If the company disputes the finding, this is the line that determines whether the conversation moves forward or stalls out on "what exactly were you looking at."

This is the part of the process that's easiest to do badly under deadline, when a finding surfaces the week before an engagement letter is due and someone is reconstructing which pass showed what. A quarterly screen that already logs the change, the dates and the flagged sites by holding lets the engagement letter cite the same record the screen produced instead of someone's memory of a map from six weeks ago.

ESG Screening runs that quarterly pass across the portfolio, flags deforestation, flaring, tailings-footprint change and encroachment site by site, and hands back a risk map and change log per holding, built so the dates and the delta line drop straight into a letter without anyone reconstructing the record from memory. If your next engagement letter needs a site finding that can survive a counsel read, see how the quarterly screen works.

← Back to the blog